Expand mobile version menu

Interviews

Insider Info

Peter Howell says the thing he most enjoys about being a film critic is probably "the aspect of discovery." He usually gets to see films before the public does.

"If possible, I see them without getting too much advance notice on what they're on," says Howell.

"I just saw a film this morning that I didn't have a chance to learn what it was about, and so I went into it totally cold. It's always interesting when you get to see what an artist has in mind before it has been filtered through a whole lot of other people."

The two most important qualities a film critic should have, says Howell, are a keen mind and a love of movies.

"I think you really have to love film, and I think you have to love all kinds of film," he says. "You just have to have a passion for it. It's not something you can approach as a hobby or as half measures or even as a job. It's got to be an absolute passion or you just can't do it."

There's another quality film reviewers should have, says Howell. It might surprise you: A high degree of stamina.

"I see between five and 10 movies a week," Howell explains. "During a film festival, I might see 20 or 30 movies a week. [And] there's a lot of stuff at home, like if you're catching up on a previous film by a director and you might want to refresh what you saw before, or if you missed a film that was important you can get it on video and watch that. I always try and do that. You often feel obliged to read the book, [too].... I don't always think that the book is required reading, but it helps sometimes."

Dan Kois is a freelance film critic whose reviews appear in the Washington Post and Village Voice, among other publications. He offers these four suggestions for aspiring film critics:

"Suggestion number one is to watch as many movies as you possibly can. If you are interested enough in movies to be a film critic, you're probably already doing that. But watch new movies that are coming out, watch old movies that you hear about, watch random movies that are on... when you happen to turn on the TV, just watch everything.

"Number two is to read widely. That is to say, read lots of critics that you like and get a sense of how criticism works and how good writers write about movies. But also read magazines and books and non-fiction and novels and things that are interesting to you to give yourself the broad base of knowledge that you need to be able to talk about pop culture in an interesting way. If you've never read a novel in your life, you'll be a bad film critic, no matter how much you know about movies.

"Three, I would try to take some kind of film production class at some point... even if you have no intention of ever making a movie. Going through the process of seeing what it's like on a set, what it's like to try and operate a camera, what it's like to try and edit something together, will give you a great appreciation for those things when you see them done well or badly on a movie screen.

"Number four, start writing now. Don't wait for somebody to hire you to write for them, because no one ever will. Start a blog, or start a Tumblr, or start tweeting, or do movie reviews on your Facebook page, or just write them at home. But start writing about movies now because the way you get better is by practicing, and the way you get noticed is by having things out there that people like to read."

If you want to be a film critic, you can get started right away, says Steve Biodrowski. He's the administrator-editor of Cinefantastique Online.

"You can always start your own blog and hope you get some attention," says Biodrowski. "So you have more than just two or three writing samples, you've got an entire [blog or website], and you can say, 'Look, I've got a following, if you publish my stuff there's X number of readers who are going to follow along.'"

Biodrowski also suggests becoming extremely knowledgeable about certain types of movies. Then you can become known for your expertise in those areas.

"I think specialization is probably a way to go these days because there's so many people out there writing about this stuff," he says. "So there may not be a huge audience for... Italian movies or whatever, but if you make yourself the person who is the expert on that, it's probably a good thing."

At the same time, film critics benefit by exposing themselves to a broad range of topics. Reading widely will make you a better writer and a more thoughtful reviewer.

"Nobody wants to read somebody who doesn't have a decent command of the language," says Marilyn Ferdinand. She's an independent film reviewer who operates a site called Ferdy on Films.

"I truly think the best reviewers are people who have a very broad knowledge in a wide variety of fields, not only in the other arts like literature, theater and music, but also things you might not expect, like history and even something like economics," she says.

"If you're covering certain types of documentaries, it's helpful to provide background, to give a rounded picture of the film that you're seeing, not just say, 'This is my opinion, like it or lump it.'"

Howell encourages anyone seriously interested in film criticism to stick with it. Despite the discouraging job numbers and the uncertainty, over the long run the cream always rises to the top, he says.

"If you really want to do it, find a way to do it," he says. "And I think that's in any kind of job.

"I think there will be a future for film criticism -- what form exactly it's hard to predict, but I think people are always going to be interested in intelligent discussion of an art form as important as film, and film is the most important art form of the past century," says Howell.

"There's no other art form that has as much appeal as movies do, so I find it hard to believe that we're getting to an era where people would not want to have critics of some kind. The big question is, 'In what form will we engage with those critics?'"

Contact

  • Email Support
  • 1-800-GO-TO-XAP (1-800-468-6927)
    From outside the U.S., please call +1 (424) 750-3900
  • North Dakota Career Resource Network
    ndcrn@nd.gov | (701) 328-9733

Support